When Goodbye Means Forever... is het debuutalbum van I Killed The Prom Queen en kwam in 2003 uit op Resist Records. In 2004 kwam het album ook in de Verenigde Staten uit op Eulogy Records.
Track listing
- Forever Will Come to an End (Intro) – 0:56
- When Goodbye Means Forever... – 3:57
- To Kill Tomorrow – 3:36
- Upon a Rivers Sky – 4:18
- Pointed to My Heart – 3:43
- Death Certificate for a Beauty Queen – 4:54
- Roses, Post Cards & Machine Gun Kisses – 3:48
- Forgiveness Is Murder – 4:15
- Portraits Dreams & Memories – 3:50
- Are You Playing Dead – 4:25
- My Best Wishes - 4:01